How to Use the Same Method for Add/Update in a Doctrine App

This post is more than 18 months old. Since technology changes to rapidly, this content may be out of date (but that's not always the case). Please remember to verify any technical or programming information with the current release.

I’m a huge fan of the service architecture paradigm - and that means that I use services in my controllers to handle persistence. I wanted to abstract the add and update methods from my services and put them into an abstract class. In addition, I didn’t want to have to specify the exact method - I just wanted to call save on the entity. Finally, I wanted to log it properly and verbosely.

So, this is what I did (I’ll explain afterward):


namespace app\Entity;

interface EntityInterface


namespace app\Service;

abstract class AbstractService
  public function __construct(
    Doctrine\ORM\EntityManager $entityManager, 
    Psr\Log\LoggerInterface $logger
  ) {
    $this->entityManager = $entityManager;
    $this->logger = $logger;
  public function save(Entity\EntityInterface $entity)
    $status = $this->entityManager->contains($entity) ? 'Updated' : 'Added';
      sprintf('%s entity %s', $status, get_class($entity)), 
      ['entity' => $entity]
    return $this;

So, first of all, just to make sure our save() method was working on an entity, I made sure all entities use the EntityInterface interface. That’s pretty simple and the easiest way to kind of guarantee that the incoming object could be an entity that doctrine manages.

Next, a call to EntityManager::contains() which determines if the current entity is managed by doctrine. If it is, that means that we’re working with an entity that needs to be updated. If it doesn’t contain it, chances are that the object does not represent an existing entity in the system. (One caveat - it could be a detached entity but I rarely work with those in my application so I didn’t check for that.) Then, it calls persist() and flush() just on that entity. Finally, the logging message is programmatically created: Added/Updated entity “entity name” - so for example: Added entity myApp\Entity\User - and the context logged is the actual entity.


Return to All Posts